Authors

David Ing + David Mallery

Abstract

Session Description

  • Context: As communities navigate complex ecological and economic disruptions, our approaches to systemic transformation often stall because they rely on inherited, mechanistic 20th-century metaphors. Dominant economic models typically conceptualize the world through "analytic formism" or "mechanism"—viewing systems as straight lines, predictable machine parts, or structural-metabolic inputs/outputs. However, true sustainability transformations require embracing relational, processual, and pluralistic ways of knowing.
  • Intervention: The first part of this workshop introduces Stephen C. Pepper’s (1942) four relatively adequate World Hypotheses (formism, mechanism, contextualism, and organicism) as foundational epistemological tools for ecological economics. It then expands upon this foundation using David Ing's emerging contextual-dyadic thinking, which extends the number of World Hypotheses. Finally, we explore a non-exhaustive list of "Ways that Meaning Comes Together." These are unvalidated extracts generated by AI models—representing alternative philosophies of science drawn from global cultures (e.g., Indigenous kinship, Islamic civilizational epistemology, Chinese classical yinyang)—which present broader pluralistic lenses for understanding social ecological systems.
  • Action/Methodology: Moving beyond a standard lecture, this session utilizes participatory systems-mapping. Participants will be divided into small groups and provided with a contemporary social ecological challenge (e.g., coastal adaptation or post-growth policy design). Groups will apply contrasting root metaphors—ranging from Pepper’s established four hypotheses to the unvalidated, cross-cultural "Ways that Meaning Comes Together"—to the same problem, co-discovering how the epistemological lens shapes the proposed economic and ecological interventions.

Relevance to the Theme

  • This workshop bridges CANSEE 2026’s "Changing Tides" theme by directly addressing the intersection of Transitions and Transformations and Rooted Communities. Disruption and renewal cannot be mapped using the mechanistic frameworks that caused our current ecological crises. By introducing alternative epistemologies (e.g., processual-relational approaches, Native Science, and Contextualism), this session equips participants with the cognitive tools to understand the social and material dimensions of post-capitalist transformation. It highlights how recognizing the deep, underlying metaphors of place and context—moving from "straight lines" to "rhythms and anticipation"—is essential for rebuilding enduring, reciprocal ties between communities and their territories.

Learning Objectives / Outcomes

  • By the end of this interactive workshop, participants will be able to:
    • Identify and critique the dominant root metaphors (Formism, Mechanism) underlying traditional economic and policy frameworks.
    • Understand alternative processual-relational epistemologies, including Contextualism, Organicism, and Indigenous ways of knowing (e.g., relational kinship, wayfaring, and rhythmic dyads).
    • Apply pluralistic root metaphors to contemporary social ecological challenges, demonstrating how shifting one's epistemological lens generates radically different strategies for community resilience and systemic transitions.

Citation

David Ing + David Mallery, “Ways That Meaning Comes Together: Root Metaphors, Relational Systems, and Enduring Economies” CANSEE 2026 Changing Tides, Workshop, Membertou, Nova Scotia, October 7, 2026,

.

Content

Previous Post Next Post

2026/10/07 Ways That Meaning Comes Together: Root Metaphors, Relational Systems, and Enduring Economies